Skip to content

REFLN category has no Set category links: is this a problem? #34

@jamesrhester

Description

@jamesrhester

Currently the REFLN category has no Set category links, and therefore is relying on implicit linking with other categories in order to be interpreted. Other dictionaries (e.g. modulated structures, powder) use this category, and so any new keys that are defined in the multiblock dictionary must be compatible with them.

Given that REFLN contains both model and observation, there is a dependence on the structure category (model) and (somehow) diffrn. However, for single crystal, multiple crystals can contribute, at the extreme end liquid flow experiments might contribute thousands, so there is no single _diffrn.id that can be associated with a particular hkl. In single crystal, separate observed reflections (diffrn_refln) are merged to a final reflection, thus removing the unique link to diffrn (and exptl_crystal).

As a first suggestion:

  1. We add _refln.structure_id as a key data name linked to _structure.id.
  2. We add _diffrn_refln.merged_id as a non-key data name pointing to _refln.id

Given the above, I think we have all the information needed to calculate/find values of all non-key datanames in REFLN, particularly F_meas and F_calc: for a given row we have a structure via _refln.structure_id. We need wavelength to do the calculation, which we find by backtracing the _diffrn_refln.merged_id -> _refln.id link, then _diffrn.id for that particular _diffrn_refln.id gives us our radiation source via _diffrn.id -> _diffrn_radiation.id. The wavelength used is the weighted sum of those listed in diffrn_radiation_wavelength - as long as the peaks haven't been spread out so far that they are considered distinct. That's a topic for the core DMG.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions